Bed and Breakfast Yorkshire Dales - Guest Comments

Guest Comments

Louise and David are very humbled and appreciative of the wonderful comments posted on-line or in the guest book.  For four years in a row these amazing reviews have scored The Old Town Hall Redmire 9.9 (out of 10) for's Guest Review Award and 99% excellent (1% very good) on TripAdvisor.



Below you will find comments from our guest book.  We would like to thank everyone for their kindness and support.

24/10/19  -  Beautiful place, really enjoyed our stay.  Felt very looked after.  Thank you so much.  (S&O, Doncaster)

17/10/19  -  Absolutely lovely stay - such welcoming hosts.  Thank you for the suggested route which we thoroughly enjoyed.  (P,L,J, Cambridge)

13/10/19  -  Lovely.  Great breakfast.  Lovely hosts.  Couldn't be better.  (A&R, Sheffield)

11/10/19  -  A wonderful stay with great food and hosts.  We will be back (again)!  (M&C, St Andrews)

09/10/19  -  Beautiful room, fantastic stay.  Thank you.  (C, Oswestry)

07/10/19  -  Like a home.  (A&T, Germany)

06/10/19  -  Fantastic - excellence all round.  (E&R, Cambridge)

06/10/19  -  Beautiful night away to celebrate our engagement.  Would definitely return.  (L&W, Doncaster)

06/10/19  -  Just perfect in every way.  (S&F, Benfleet)

04/10/19  -  Beyond immaculate.  (M&H, York)

01/10/19  -  Thanks for helping to make our celebration very special.  (D,A,F,M,A&P, Wilmslow)

30/09/19  -  It was indeed a lovely experience.  I admire your care and attention to detail.  Couldn't have asked for more!  (B&S, Harrogate)

30/09/19  -  How to run a perfect B&B.  Simple.  Louise could write the book and David could carve the template.  SORTED.  (B&I. Haslemere)

28/09/19  -  Another golden buzzer moment.  Fantastic.  Thank you.  (N&A, Thetford)

27/09/19  -  Fantastic stay - loved the breakfast.  Thank you.  (C&B, Thatcham)

27/09/19  -  Just stunning.  (D&V, Chesterfield)

22/09/19  -  Wonderful stay had by all.  (A&N, USA)

19/09/19  -  We loved our visit.  Food excellent.  Room excellent.  (P&G, Watford)

15/09/19  -  Outstanding.  If only we knew we would have stayed longer.  Thanks and goodbye for now.  (P&B, Staplehurst)

14/09/19  -  Brilliant as ever.  We love it.  (M&P, Wolvey)

13/09/19  -  Wonderful.  Thank you.  (B&D, Durham)

12/09/19  -  Wonderful place and hospitality.  Breakfast and cakes were great.  Thank you.  (J&M, USA)

11/09/19  -  Wonderful.  (P&S, Rossendale)

09/09/19  -  Deserves the 5* rating.  Lovely room.  Delicious breakfast which set us up for the day.  Thank you David and Louise.  (L&M, St Ives)

07/09/19  -  FAB-U-LOUS,  (R&C, Doncaster)

04/09/19  -  Very cosy room, clean and amazing breakfast.  (A&L, Wigan)

04/09/19  -  A wonderful place!  Had a lovely 5 days here.  Thank you.  (F&M, London)

03/09/19  -  We had a really lovely stay.  The bed is very comfy.  Clean room and the breakfast was gorgeous.  (A&R, Malton)

02/09/19  -  Fantastic room and delicious breakfast.  Thank you.  (S&A, Melton Mowbray)

01/09/19  -  Another amazing stay.  Everything was perfect.  Will be back again.  (P&Z, Manchester)

31/08/19  -  Amazing stay. Thank you.  (A&G, Cromer)

30/08/19  -  Fabastic two night stay.  Thank you for all your help etc. 5 star plus!  Will most certianly come again.  (M&J, Bonsall)

25/08/19  -  Thank you for making our first trip to Yorkshire wonderful  Fantastic hosts, beautiful accommodation and breakfast.  Also the string came in very handy!  (D&C, Hemel Hempstead)

21/08/19  -  Wonderful stay for our 25th anniversary.  Best B&B we've ever stayed at.  Perfect in every way!  (D&B, Rotherham)

21/08/19  -  Thank you for a lovely stay.  You were both so lovely and helpful.  Could not be better - worth 10 stars!.  (Y&G, Lockerbie)

19/08/19  -  Lovely stay thank you.  You well deserve the awards.  (M&V, Aberdeen)

19/08/19  -  Delightful!  Thanks so much.  (D&A. Chipping Warden)

19/08/19  -  Thank you.  Fantastic stay.  (H&D, Gainsborough) 

15/08/19  -  Another fantastic stay.  Thank you for making us so welcome.  All so lovely.  (S,C,C,&N, Sittingbourne)

12/08/19  -  Another wonderful stay with fabulous breakfasts and spotless accommodation.  Many thanks.  (J&D, York)

10/08/19  -  Beautiful place, lovely hosts, everything perfect.  Thank you.  (D&S, Macclesfield)

08/08/19  -  Our son, who stayed here 2/3 years ago, was absolutely right.  A wonderful B&B.  (F&J, Manchester)

07/08/19  -  Another lovley stay.  Thank you so much.  (J, N & N, Melbourne Derbyshire)

04/08/19  -  What a spectacular place.  Without a doubt the best B&B we've ever stayed at.  Would definitely recommend.  Can't wait for breakfast.  Thank you for having us.  (D&A, Brough)

04/08/19  -  Thank you both for making us feel so welcome - we really felt at home here.  See you again!!  (S&T, Birmingham)

04/08/19  -  Thank you so much for a fantastic stay.  (D&S, Liversedge)

01/08/19  -  Thank you once again for yet another lovely stay.  (H&N, Knaresborough)

01/08/19  -  Thank you for a lovely stay.  Lovely breakfast and accommodating hosts.  (R&N, Beverley)

31/07/19  -  Many thanks for a wonderful stay.  Lovely breakfast, room and hosts.  (T&G, Doncaster)

29/07/19  -  Wow, what a place! Thank you.  (J&A, Netherlands)

27/07/19  -  Lovely comfortable bed, delicious breakfast, enjoyed our stay.  Thank you.  (J&K, Blackburn)

25/07/19  -  Great time had, fabulous B&B.  Best ever stayed in thank you for a great friendly welcome.  (R&M, Abingdon)

25/07/19  -  Fantastic place, lovely hosts.  Will definitely be back.  Thank you.  (C&S, Bradford)

22/07/19  -  Second visit as the first was so perect.  Not disappointed this time either - absolutely amazing.  We love this place!  (K&J, Wallsend)

21/07/19  -  A wonderful stay here - the best B&B ever!  Perfection all round.  Thank you.  (D&M, Berkhamstead)

18/07/19  -  A lovely little B&B.  Louise your hospitailty is so lovely.  Very relaxed, just what we needed.  Thank you for going out of your way for our electric car.  (A&K, Grimsby)

16/07/19  -  Great hospitality and lovely return to Yorkshire with my spanish family.  (C, Spain)

16/07/19  -  Magnefico  (J&H, Spain)

14/07/19  -  Thank you for a f-a-b-u-l-o-u-s stay, will be visiting again.  Certainly lived up to the reviews on TripAdvisor.  (C&C, Doncaster)

13/07/19  -  We have stayed in many B&Bs but this is by far the best.  Everything perfect.  Wonderful room, breakfast and hosts.  Thank you so much,  (J&T, Hastings)

10/07/19  -  By far the best B&B we have ever been to.  Better than a 5* hotel.  Everything so lovely, from the room, facilities to the wonderful breakfast and home-made cakes and preserves.  Cannot praise enough.  Excellent hosts too.  Thank you.  (J&C, Calverton)

10/07/19  -  Thank you for your lovely hospitality.  It has been such a nice way to end our UK visit.  PS we loved the banana cake  (W&M, Australia)

05/07/19  -  Thank you for a realy great stay - lovely room, fantastic breakfasts and many little extras which are much appreciated.  One being the cakes and coffee in the afternoon.  Will be back.  (J&B, Brigg)

05/07/19  -  A perfect hidden gem with great hosts.  A wonderful break with lots of lovely little extras.  We hope to be back.  Many thanks Louise and David.  (D&D, Lincoln)

04/07/19  -  Two nights, wonderful as always.  Thank you both. (J&J, Newport Pagnell)

03/07/19  -  First time here but we will be returning.  Lovely room with great attention to detail.  Best breakfast ever.  Thank you.  (V&J, Uxbridge)

02/07/19  -  Two nights of luxury thank you.  Can't fault it.  We very much enjoyed staying here, will definitely be back.  (G&J, Bexley)

30/06/19  -  Beautiful B&B.  Great breakfast - thank you.  (D&C, Liechenstein)

29/06/19  -  What a lovely B&B.  Absolutely wonderful.  (J&P, Southampton)

29/06/19  -  A very short stay!!  Lovely place - must return to explore the beautiful area.  (P&S, Chichester)

23/06/19  -  Two nights of bliss.  Perfect.  Exceptional.  By far the best B&B we have ever stayed in in over 50 years of married life  (V&H, Burscough)

22/06/19  -  Perfect x (M&T, Wembley)

21/06/19  -  Very comfortable.  Friendly helpful hosts.  Lovely breakfast.  (C&R, Watlington)

16/06/19  -  Couldn't ask for more.  Thank you for allowing us to use your wonderful place for our wedding weekend.  (R&R, Catterick)

12/06/19  -  Lovely relaxing break here.  Always feel spoilt.  Will be staying again - thank you.  (C&M, Pickering)

10/06/19  -  Lovely B&B - excellent hosts and facilities.  Would definitely recommend.   (A&R, Huntingdon)

08/06/19  -  We've had a most enjoyable stay in this top-class B&B.  Thank you so much!  (R&J, Ilkley)

07/06/19  -  Our first time here.... and won't be our last!  We have loved every minute of our stay.  The rooms are wonderful and the breakfasts are amazing.  Dave and Louise your attention to detail is out of this world.  You have made us feel so welcome and you are so very kind and helpful.. We can't thank you enough.  (H&D, Renhold)

05/06/19  -  Our 2nd visit to this exceptional B&B.  David and Louise take great care in making guests welcome.  Thank you.  (G&E, York)

03/06/19  -  Wow I think this is the nicest B&B I've ever stayed in - and I've stayed in a lot.  Peaceful, friendly,and beautifully decorated.  I'll come back to stay.  - Just lovely.  (L, Durham)

03/06/19  -  This is not only an excellent B&B, it is made with love for your visitors and you feel it.  Thanks.  (M&B, Germany)

02/06/19  -  Definitely one of the best B&Bs we've ever stayed in - amazing breakfast.  (M&L, Newport Pagnell)

01/06/19  -  Amazing stay.  (L&J, Chippenham)

01/06/19  -  Absolute perfection!  (S&D, Chippenham)

30/05/19  -  An amazing stay!  Beautifully furnished room, delicious home-cooked breakfast and delightful attention to detail. (J&F, Wigan)

28/05/19  -  Thanks for a brilliant chilled out stay.  (S&A, Leeds)

27/05/19  -  Thanks for a great stay.  Great breakfast. 

25/05/19  -  Very welcoming, lovely accommodation and breakfast.  Keep baking the cakes David!  (C&J, Nottingham)

24/05/19  -  Great accommodation, excellent food.  Thank you for your hospitality.  (K&J, Nuneaton)

23/05/19  -  Beautiful B&B.  Amazing breakfasts and lovely hosts.  Very accommodating.  More than happy to return.  (D&S, Durham)

21/05/19  -  Lovely stay, lovely food.  Lovely hosts.  Thank you.  (A&J, Chesterfield)

20/05/19  -  Thank you for another lovely weekend.  Wonderful food and excellent room.  (K&M, Bolton)

19/05/19  -  Loveley comfortable stay.  Spotless and wonderful breakfasts.  Thank you.  (M&K, Darley)

18/05/19  -  Very nice room (M&K, Norway)

12/05/19  -  Great weekend away, lovely room, amazing breakfast.  (S&S, Scunthorpe)

12/05/19  -  A perfect weekend.  Everyhting, without exception, was just lovley - thank you.  (C&P, Lytham St Annes)

11/05/19  -  Absolutely fabulous!  Lovely room, delicious breakfasts and great company. (J&J, York)

10/05/19  -  Awesome - says it all!  (D&P, Cotswolds)

08/05/19  -  Excellent as usual.  We'll be back for more.  Take care.  (E&K, Sheringham)

07/05/19  -  Fantastic place, fabulous hosts - can't wait to come back.  Thank youxx (P&S, Huddersfield)

06/05/19  -  Lovely stay, fantastic room and breakfast.  (A&P, Bolton)

06/05/19  -  Thank you for a lovley break.  Wonderful food and beautiful room.  Fanatastic hosts.  (I&W, Malton)

05/05/19  -  Amazing stay.  What a gem of a B&B.  David and Louise are very welcoming, helpful but not intrusive.  Looking forward to coming back.  Thank you.  (P&J, York)

02/05/19  -  Fantastic stay.  Couldn't fault a thing.  Room beautiful, breakfast brilliant and David and Louise so welcoming.  Thank you.  (T&S, Guildford)

29/04/19  -  Lovely room, super breakfasts and very knowledgable and helpful hosts.  Couldn't have asked for any more.  Hope to be back in the future.  (D&K, Norfolk)

28/04/19  -  Lovely room, very tasty breakfast.  Very pleasant stay.  (G&R, Leeds)

23/04/19  -  We enjoyed every minute of our stay, from arriving & meeting lovely hosts David and Louise, to leaving.  Food cake etc lovely, room etc so relaxing.  We will be recommending to everyone and will certainly be coming back.  Thank you so much for a great weekend.  (M&S, York)

21/04/19  -  Lovely relaxing stay with super soft towels!!  (N&T, Horsforth)

21/04/18  -  Thank you for another fantastic stay.  Everything was perfect!  (B&S, Denby Dale)

18/04/19  -  Perfect stay.  (A&T, Scunthorpe)

15/04/19  -  Lovely place to stay, everything just perfect and lovely hosts.  (J&S, Middlewich)

14/04/19  -  Wonderful!  So friendly and possibly the best breakfast ever!!  (C&C, York)

14/04/19  -  The friendliest B&B we've ever come across.  Hosts are faultless, stay was faultless.  We are so sad to leave.  Can't wait to visit again.  (S&M, Milton Keynes)

12/04/19  -  Fantastic place, very well looked after.  Will definitely be back.  (D&A, Newcastle-upon-Tyne)

11/04/19  -  This is our 9th time to The Old Town Hall.  The standard is always excellent.  The breakfasts are always of a high standard.  Excellent hosts.  (L&T, Barnsley)

08/04/19  -  Beautiful stay and lovely owners.  Thank you.  (S&M, Brough)

07/04-19  -  An amazing stay - excellent room, fabulous breakfasts and David and Louise are superb hosts.  We will be back!  (J&N, Tickhill)

04/04/19  -  Wonderful in everyway.  (R&M, Glasgow)

01/04/19  -  Perfect everything, including the hosts!  (J&D, Leeds)

31/03/19  -  A superb B&B - truly outstanding.  Beautiful room, wonderful hosts, delicious food and fantastic scenery and walks nearby.  Cannot recommend highly enough!  (E&S, Norfolk)

31/03/19  -  We have had a lovely stay, room is incredible, amazing attention to detail.  Food was delicious.  Louise and David are super hosts.  (J&A, Heckmondwicke)

28/03/19  -  Amazing stay - everything lovely - We'll be back.  (J&D, York)

24/03/19  -  Lovely stay, thank you!x  (E&R, Ellenthorpe)

23/03/19  -  Fantastic stay.  Lovely room, fabulous breakfast, definitely coming back!  (J&J, Leeds)

22/03/19  -  A 6 star venue with food and service to match!  Many thanks!  (J&N, Pocklington)

22/03/19  -  The Old Town Hall was recommended to us and has far exceeded our expectations.  Your attention to detail in the rooms and at the table is exceptional.  You both well deserve your 5 star awards.  (S&K, Leeds)

21/03/19  -  B&B doesn't come any better.  Superb accommodation and great helpful hosts.  Look forward to return in the future.  (P&S, Mawdsley)

18/03/19  -  Very comfortable room - great breakfast - great location.  (P&M, Preston)

17/03/19  -  Perfect stay.  Thank you Louise and David, you are both lovely, the food was fabulous and accommodation amazing.  We will be back. 5*  (P&Z, Stockport)

16/03/19  -  WOW! Fantastic!! Thank you.  (N&J, Barnsley)

15/03/19  -  100% everything.  (B&A, Sunderland)

13/03/19  -  Well what can we say - Louise and David have been the perfect hosts, the room was a joy to stay in and the food was 5*.  David, I will enjoy the jam and marmalade and miss your homemade cake on an afternoon!!  Everything is a credit to you both.  10/10  Hope to see you again.  (M&J, Filey)

10/03/19  -  Thank you for everything.  Lovely hosts, fabulous room & food.  We will certainly be back soon xx (S&D, Norwell)

09/03/19  -  Wonderful place, great hosts with amazing attention to detail.  Everything is thought of.  The best towels and dressing gowns ever!!!  (C&T, Barnsley)

07/03/19  -  Fab three days, loved every minute.  (I&M, Blackpool)

06/03/19  -  Superb B&B, the hosts are just lovely.  Food and stay has been brilliant.  So relaxing and well looked after, nothing was too much trouble..  (D&R, Topcliffe)

02/03/19  -  Another superb weekend, so friendly and relaxing - every detail attended to.  We'll be back!!.  (A&B, Market Rasen)

02/03/19  -  Our 4th visit and not our last.  So relaxing and lovely to see old friends.  (D&C, Market Rasen)

01/03/19  -  Thank you so much, Louise and David, for your wonderful hospitality and for making us feel so much at home.  The best B&B we've ever stayed in, by a long way.  (K&M, Haxby)

25/02/19  -  We have had a perfect weekend and will be back soon.  Thank you for everything.  (E&J, Sheffield)

24/02/19  -  Fantastic hosts, beautiful room.  Great breakfast.  5 star all day long.  (L&K, Castleford)

23/02/19  -  Thank you Louise and David.  Says 5 star and 5 star it is.  (C&K, Ashwell)

22/02/19  -  Lovely room, amazing hosts.  David and Louise made a stay in their fab B&B perfect.  Thank you both xx (P&C, Ingleby)

21/02/19  -  Beautiful room and amazing food.  Perfect stay - Thank you Louise and David.  (L&R, St Albans)

17/02/19  -  A really great trip.  The hosts were amazing and gave us a lot of local insight.  Thank you, oh... and the best cooked breakfast we have ever had xx (R&E, Tockwith)

14/02/19  -  Lovely to stay with old friends!  Louise and David are excellent hosts and The Old Town Hall is perfect.  Thank you.  (G&V, York)

10/02/19  -  Stunning B&B and village.  Absolutely loved it.  Brilliant hosts, very professional but friendly and welcoming.  Nothing was too much trouble.  We will be back. Thank you.  (K&J, Newcastle)

10/02/19  -  Excellent hosts, beautiful B&B.  We're leaving relaxed and will return.  (K&M, Bolton)

03/02/19  -  Wonderful weekend.  Thank you for a lovely stay.  (C&E, York)

03/02/19  -  Terrific weekend.  Excellent hospitality, friendly with an eye for detail.  We will return.  Thank you.  (S&K, Nottingham)

27/01/19  -  Second time - just as good as the first - thank you.  (S&A, Barnsley)

22/01/19  -  Wonderful place to stay.  Excellent attention to detail.  Very hearty and tasty breakfast.  Will recommend.  Massive room too!  (C&L, London)

20/01/19  -  Thank you very much for a lovely weekend.  The breakfast was delicious - we felt very welcome.  Lovely room.  (M&A, Alford)

19/01/19  -  A lovely stay.  Many thanks.  (B&J, Leeds)

07/01/19  - Thank you.  Fantastic place.  Very comfortable and great breakfast  10/10.  (P, London) 

Click here to read comments from 2018

Click here to read comments from 2017

Click here to read comments from 2016

Click here to read comments from 2015